Skip to main content Skip to search

YU News

YU News

Orthodox Forum Revisits a Critical Jewish Issue

Twentieth Volume Examines Challenges Orthodox Community Faces Relating to Jews of Other Religious Ideologies This fall, the Orthodox Forum is celebrating its 20th publication by revisiting a past topic through new and broader lenses. This most recent volume, entitled “The Relationship of Orthodox Jews with Believing Jews of Other Religious Ideologies and Non-Believing Jews” is edited by Rabbi Adam Mintz and takes a fresh look at a theme discussed at the Forum’s conference on “Jewish Tradition and the Non-Traditional Jew,” published in 1992. Each publication is based on papers reviewed by participants at the Orthodox Forum’s annual conference held a year prior to publication. “Much has changed,” writes Rabbi Mintz in his introduction regarding the Jewish community’s development since the publication of the 1992 volume. “The trend toward increased affiliation within Judaism as expressed in the religious, cultural and political arenas has brought many non-Orthodox Jews and previously secular Jewish organizations back to the framework of the Jewish community.” Rabbi Robert Hirt, series editor and vice president emeritus of Rabbi Issac Elchanan Theological Seminary (RIETS), echoes similar sentiments regarding the necessity of this current volume. “The world has changed since we first engaged in this topic. Hopefully this volume will serve as a vehicle to think more inclusively for Orthodox and non-Orthodox Jews alike.” Rabbi Yona Reiss, The Max and Marion Grill Dean of RIETS, was one of 13 contributors in this monumental volume. “The topic of relationships among Jews of different denominational affiliations is particularly ripe for discussion at the current time,” said Rabbi Reiss. “There is an increasing desire to break barriers and restore a sense of communal unity. The challenge is in seizing the opportunity while remaining faithful to halachic norms.” The 20th volume of the Orthodox Forum has provided its editors with a chance to reflect on its mission. According to Rabbi Hirt, there are three goals of the Orthodox Forum. The first is to produce a body literature for Modern Orthodox Jews that is “authoritative but not authoritarian.” In this vein, Rabbi Hirt consistently aims to attract interdisciplinary groups of roshei yeshiva, pulpit rabbis, academics, Jewish communal professionals and educators to participate in the Forum. This allows for every Forum publication to include articles ranging from topics on halacha, philosophy, history and sociology. Rabbi Hirt’s second objective is to create a community of Jewish thinkers who would not commonly find an arena to meet with one another. “The Forum produces a sense of social cohesiveness,” said Rabbi Hirt. “Each participant shares his or her thinking of something that has been thought about thoughtfully.” The third goal, Rabbi Hirt explained, is that “the Orthodox Forum provides a place for Jewish leaders to raise topics that could not be raised elsewhere.” To date, the Orthodox Forum has produced over 200 articles. In addition, every article from volumes 11 to 18 are available free atYUTorah.org. The subsequent volume, which addresses “The Next Generation of Modern Orthodoxy” edited by Rabbi Shmuel Hain, is set for publication in 2011.